Episode 2: Care as control
In this episode, host Jessie Sullivan (University College London) speaks with Olivia Petie (University of Birmingham) and Megan Crossley (Lancaster University) about care "from above" to ask who the state sees as deserving of care and how those framings shape everyday life for migrants in the UK.
We look at the stark contrast between bespoke routes created for some groups and the hostile, securitised response to people seeking asylum via small boats - discuss how the language of care can be mobilised to legitimise border violence and obscure the structural conditions driving dangerous crossings in the first place. We share examples from our own research, unpacking the myth of asylum hotels as ‘luxury’ spaces and discuss the far right hostility and violence facing asylum hotel residents. We also consider how asylum support policies frame control as care while leaving people destitute, disconnected and constantly on the move.
Mentioned resources:
- Crossley, M. (2026). Careless Bordering: Photovoice accounts from refugees and people seeking asylum in Northwest England. [Doctoral Thesis, Lancaster University]. Lancaster University. https://doi.org/10.17635/lancaster/thesis/3238 (Please note: This thesis is currently unavailable online however contact m.crossley@lancaster.ac.uk to receive a copy)
- Crossley, M. (forthcoming). Careless Bordering: Care as a technology of control in UK asylum governance
- Petie, O., Phillimore, J. and Allsopp, A. (2025) ‘Exploring hospitality, hostility and (un)home in hotel accommodation for asylum seekers in the United Kingdom’, Hospitality & Society 15(1): 23-44.
- Phillimore, J., Petie, O. (2024) ‘What life is like for the asylum seekers in hotels being attacked by far right groups’, The Conversation, https://theconversation.com/what-life-is-like-for-the-asylum-seekers-in-hotels-being-attacked-by-far-right-groups-236020
- Sheikh, Rahil and Kateryna Pavlyuk, (6 February 2026) ‘Number of homeless refugees in England soars, BBC finds.’ BBC. https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/cy9y3n43192o
Further suggested resources:
- Sirriyeh, A. (2018) Politics of Compassion: Immigration and Asylum Policy. Bristol University Press.
- Darling, J. (2022) Systems of Suffering: Dispersal and the Denial of Asylum. Pluto Press
- Darling, J. and Burridge, A. (2025) Hotels, refuge, and the rise of carceral hospitality, Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers, 50 (4).
Active listening questions:
- The hosts mention that care can be "wrapped in the language of support" in ways that make resistance harder. Can you think of other contexts (beyond migration) where the language of care might be used to soften or justify control?
- If you were designing a UK asylum accommodation and support system from scratch, guided by the critical understandings of care discussed in this episode, what might you do differently?
- This episode critiques the framing of asylum seekers as either "illegal migrants" living in luxury or vulnerable victims needing rescue. What do both of these framings leave out?
Transcript
Jessie
And. You. Welcome back to the Between Borders podcast. This season we are exploring care and migration. We're a collective of researchers who work on different topics relating to precarious migration. We reflect on how people working or doing research in this area can better support people who are moving or have moved across borders. I'm Jessie Sullivan, and today I'll be your host.
2
:Jessie
This season, we turn the focus to the theme of care, which has become a central theme in migration research and solidarity work, not least during and in the wake of the Covid 19 pandemic. To a large extent, this widespread interest in care has emerged in response to the increasingly uncaring and violent reality of border regimes in the UK and across the world today.
3
:Jessie
Through a series of episodes, we seek to unpack care through the lens of migration to explore different ways of understanding, care and why this matters. For a more just world. In this episode, we turn our attention to care from above, asking who is seen as deserving of care from the state and how those dominant framings in media policy and legislation shape everyday lived experiences for migrants in the UK.
4
:Jessie
Today I'll be talking to Olivia PD. Hello, and Megan Crossley. Hello, Olivia. Can you tell us a little bit about your work and how it relates to our theme of care?
5
:Olivia
Sure. Thanks, Jessie. So my research focuses on hotels as a form of precarious accommodation for people seeking asylum in the UK. As a bit of context, for those who are maybe less familiar with the UK asylum system. Whilst their application is progressed, destitute asylum seekers are effectively banned from working but are entitled to housing and a small amount of financial support from the government.
6
:Olivia
My research focuses on the accommodation aspect of this, specifically on hotels through the lens of hospitality. My research explores how hotels are being used to accommodate people seeking asylum, including the policies and processes which contribute to precarity and the effects of this on people's ability to establish a home in the UK.
7
:Jessie
Thanks for sharing those details, Olivia. We'll definitely come back to speaking about accommodation for asylum seekers in the UK. Throughout the episode, I'll tell you a bit about my research, which is about forced migrants feelings of belonging in Amman, Jordan. In addition to looking at individual practices of being present in public and private space in Amman, I'm really interested in the larger geopolitical situation and how forced migrants plight can be used and mobilized by state and more than state actors to control their actions, as well as solicit responses from other state actors.
8
:Jessie
And again, we were introduced to your research in the previous episode, but can you give us a reminder of how your research relates to care from above?
9
:Megan
Sure. Thanks, Jessie. I'm very interested in thinking about the role of care and how migration is governed in the UK. So thinking about who's cared for, how as well as who is not shown care. I've written about this developing a concept of what I call callous, bordering in an effort to draw attention to the ways in which care is unevenly distributed in accordance with someone's immigration status.
10
:Megan
In my recent research, I look at how the state withdraws care from people seeking asylum, but also how when care and welfare provision is offered, it can become another form of control. Like Olivia, I found through my research that accommodation is one of the key sites of caring infrastructure and policies where we see this play out for people who are seeking asylum.
11
:Jessie
I really appreciate your new concept of careless bordering. I really think it helps us to see the coercive control of some bordering practices.
12
:Jessie
So thinking about this question of care from above and who is worthy of care? Megan, can you provide a bit of an overview of what that means?
13
:Megan
Yes, a great question. I think if we think about care from the vantage point of the state, one of the first things that becomes visible is how deeply selective it is. So changes in law and policy around migration and humanitarian protection signal who's deemed deserving of safety, compassion and belonging, as well as who's seen as suspicious, undeserving, even disposable.
14
:Megan
And we can see this quite starkly in the contrast between bespoke visa programs for Ukrainians or people from Hong Kong, for example, and the far more hostile securitized responses to people seeking asylum who arrive through small boats. In the case of Ukraine and Hong Kong, we saw tailored routes being created and public narratives of solidarity, all underpinned by a presumption of legitimacy and deserving ness.
15
:Megan
Now, I do want to stress that these schemes are not without their own criticism. For example, they do not entitle people to the same rights that they would have if they were given refugee status. But I think certainly this exposes what the state is capable of putting in place. If it's willing to do so.
16
:Jessie
That is so interesting. It seems that it really highlights how the state has the capacity to care for certain migrants, like you said, but it's choosing how and when to mobilize its caring capacities.
17
:Megan
% in:
18
:Jessie
So how do you account for these differences in approaches by the state to different populations and their migration trends?
19
:Megan
Well, firstly, let's be clear. This isn't about pitting different countries against each other in some kind of moral competition. But what it does start to reveal is that these differences are deeply political, shaped by histories of empire and colonialism, as well as both historic and contemporary geopolitical interests. If care is extended through bespoke pathways for some, while others are met with detention, deportation and violent border controls.
20
:Megan
And what we're seeing is not some kind of universal ethic of humanitarian protection or asylum, but it's a strategic distribution of care built on the idea that some lives are inherently more worthy of welcome or of safety than others. It also challenges the idea that the border regime is inevitable, as the state shows us that it does have the capacity to create more timely, safe routes when it serves its own geopolitical interests.
21
:Megan
Unsettling the inevitability of an uncaring or careless approach to bordering, which requires us to confront these hierarchies directly.
22
:Jessie
Very interesting Meghan. So I'm seeing that both your and Olivia's work uses the concept of care to mean practices by the state instead of interpersonal practices. And as we've discussed, care is not inherently beneficial. So the state might engage in some pretty uncaring practices.
23
:Megan
Exactly. States adopt the language of care to justify practices that are, in effect, uncaring, as you say. Let's take, for example, the policies framed around stopping smuggling or ending dangerous channel crossings, which are often discussed by the government in terms of an almost humanitarian concern. This idea that we need to have stronger borders to stop smuggling networks and therefore save people's lives.
24
:Megan
The state there is positioning itself as a firm but responsible caregiver, stepping in to protect vulnerable migrants from exploitation and from harm. But if we look more closely, that framing completely shifts attention away from the structural conditions that make those journeys necessary in the first place. For example, the lack of safe and legal routes to this country, as well as the long histories of colonialism and conflicts which displace people.
25
:Megan
Instead, it places the problem squarely on these so-called criminal smugglers and risk taking migrants as individuals, rather than recognizing this more structural violence. And in doing so, it tries to legitimize the violence of the border regime, which includes making channel crossings incredibly unsafe for those who do attempt it. We end up with this kind of compromised moral project, where the so-called care being enacted by the state is conditional.
26
:Megan
It's controlling, and it's bound by citizenship or immigration status. At the end of the day, people who are effectively forced to take these dangerous routes to claim asylum in the UK and then demonized and treated very poorly. The state does not care for them. Then?
27
:Jessie
Absolutely. And the difference between the states rhetoric around caring for migrants and then their actions, notably the inherent violence of restricting access to safe routes. That difference could not be more obvious.
28
:Jessie
So Meghan just brought up the topic of how asylum seekers are treated once they arrive in the UK. And I think this is something you're interested in, Olivia. So could you speak to what you've observed around state care in the context of accommodation centers for asylum seekers?
29
:Olivia
Of course. Thanks, Jessie and Meghan. So, as you may know, the topic of hotels being used to house, people seeking asylum has received a lot of attention in recent years from politicians and the media, as well as in local communities in the media. These hotels are often presented as being luxury accommodation, five star hotels where people have spa facilities and room service, although in reality this is definitely not the case.
30
:Olivia
The people living in them are also presented as being illegal migrants, usually associated with those who have crossed the channel via small boats. Within this context, hotels are presented as being almost two caring as luxury spaces not suitable for those who are considered to be undeserving of this amount of care. As a result, hotel accommodation for people seeking asylum has been very unpopular as a policy decision and consecutive governments and home secretaries have focused on trying to close hotels, often shifting to other large sites or more hostile spaces.
31
:Olivia
dation. In the financial year:
32
:Olivia
The idea that asylum hotels are overly caring feels a real stretch to anyone who knows the realities of the system. The hotels being used often offer quite poor quality accommodation, and even nicer hotels are still very challenging places to live for long periods. Participants in my research described poor quality facilities, overcrowding, food which lacks nutritional value and restrictions on their freedom and daily lives.
33
:Olivia
e contracts, which started in:
34
:Jessie
And what are some of those realities for people living in hotels?
35
:Olivia
So one of the first things people often tell you about hotels is how bad the food is. My research has found this really varies a lot between hotels. Some hotels have cooking facilities and an onsite catering team, whereas others have prepackaged food brought in for each meal in plastic Tupperware. A whole range of issues with the food have been highlighted though, and this includes not being culturally appropriate.
36
:Olivia
A lack of nutritional value, failure to account for dietary requirements, and a lack of dignity. Mealtimes can also be challenging, with food only served at specific times, meaning people's daily activities are often dictated by short windows of free time between meals. One of the participants in my research describes having to skip breakfast every morning, because it was too late for them to be able to get to their English classes at college in time.
37
:Olivia
In addition, the majority of people are required to share rooms in hotels. This creates challenges leading to difficulty sleeping. For example, when one person is awake late talking on their phone while another tries to sleep. There's also a lack of privacy, which can cause tensions. Limited space for storing personal belongings and sometimes feelings of isolation, especially if the person you're sharing with speaks a different language.
38
:Olivia
People also frequently reported being really bored, not being able to work, and barriers to accessing college or English classes means people often have nowhere to go and nothing to do. This is compounded by a lack of communal areas and facilities in hotels, as well as having such small amounts of financial support and being limited by hotel meal times.
39
:Olivia
As I've mentioned, one of the stakeholders I interviewed for my research described how this can create tensions in their community as people are seen to be hanging around in parks and public spaces, but they actually have nowhere else to go or nothing else that they can do.
40
:Jessie
Wow. Yeah, that's also important. Olivia. Living in a hotel accommodation sounds really, really difficult. People are subject also to being moved at a moment's notice. They're really temporary. And while they're there, they can't work. So they're denied many, many forms of agency. We've seen a lot of hostility directed at the hotel accommodation spaces recently. Can you speak to that?
41
:Olivia
Of course. So when an asylum hotel is opened in a community, there's often a lot of backlash. I mean, dozens or hundreds of people may be placed in a hotel almost overnight, sometimes with very little community consultation. The people place there, as I've said, generally have very little money. They can't work, and they require support and access to some public services.
42
:Olivia
The far right has then been using these tensions that develop around these hotels to advance their political ideology, and we've seen those tensions develop into violent attacks on the people housed in these hotels through riots and extreme protests.
43
:Megan
I think they're really great points, Olivia. And I just wanted to add that often the public perception around migration and around asylum in the UK is inflated by these misleading headlines, and the constant preoccupation with immigration as a political issue. I've seen it in my own research, where some of the participants I was working with were living in a hotel targeted by far right protests, and they talked about how it made them feel really unsafe, but that they were also acutely aware of these narratives of anti asylum and anti-immigration politics, which made them feel demonized.
44
:Megan
And another man who was living in a different hotel took a photograph of the TV in the lounge, which was set to the news channel, and he described how often he and other residents would be having what he called good times, and then suddenly they would see the news about them. And he spoke about the government and his morale just going down to zero.
45
:Jessie
So it sounds like these political narratives really contribute to an emotional climate of fear and hostility, which filters down into people's everyday lives.
46
:Jessie
So just to connect back to lived experience of legislation and policies. Megan, your work focuses on people's experience in the asylum system. Can you tell us more about that?
47
:Megan
Yeah, I mean, it's such an important question because when we start thinking with people's lived experience and from the knowledge that they share, we can really start to see what these policies do. So the restrictions on people seeking asylum have meant they're effectively siloed out of the mainstream benefits system. And excluded from most of the labor market. So the vast majority of people seeking asylum are required to declare themselves officially destitute in order to access state support through what's known as asylum support, or section 95.
48
:Megan
As Olivia mentioned earlier. So in my recent work, participants consistently describe their experiences of section 95 through what I think of as three interlinked techniques of governance delay, dispersal, and deprivation. So firstly, delay people's lives are effectively suspended in a lot of ways while they wait for an initial decision on their asylum claim. People talked about feeling stuck, being unable to plan, to study, to build relationships, to move forward, and that prolonged uncertainty takes a profound psychological toll for many people.
49
:Megan
Secondly, thinking about dispersal under the banner of providing accommodation and support, people are routinely dispersed or moved to under-resourced areas with limited services and infrastructure. And thirdly, deprivation, because they're denied the right to work. People seeking asylum lack economic resources, but the level of financial support provided is set deliberately low, at around 70% of the rate of universal Credit, which is a similar benefit provided by the welfare state, with citizens and some migrants.
50
:Megan
Asylum support is currently set to 49.18 pounds per week to cover food, clothing, transport, toiletries and anything else. Somebody might need, or a measly 8.86 pound per week in hotel accommodations where meals are already provided. So, to put that into context, a weekly bus pass for someone in my area is about 19 pounds a week. Completely unaffordable if someone's living in a hotel or a large proportion of someone's budget.
51
:Megan
If they live in shared housing. And how do you think these.
52
:Jessie
Three techniques delay, disperse and deprivation linked to care?
53
:Megan
Well, the government frames these intervention interventions as a logistical necessity, even as a form of care where the state is housing and supporting people who need somewhere to live while their claims are being processed. But in practice, it's spatially, socially and economically marginalized as spam. And when we think about the low financial support that people receive while also being denied the opportunity to earn their own money legally, but some people, this pushes them into informal or precarious labor simply to get by, which then exposes them to further risk and exploitation.
54
:Megan
And what this shows is how the state puts people in precarious positions, where they're then expected to look after themselves while simultaneously denying them the capacity or the resources to do so.
55
:Jessie
So I'm hearing that the policy environment creates the need to care for migrants in this way, like it's a political choice to not allow people to work, and then to give them a fraction of the economic support they need to live. This is actually something I also found in my research in Jordan, where refugees and asylum seekers are also not allowed to work but are not guaranteed financial support from welfare systems.
56
:Jessie
And that policy effectively pushes forced migrants into the informal labor market, where they experience exploitation and really dangerous conditions. But they're not really able to contest those conditions because the legal system won't support them, because they're not supposed to work. And at the same time, people claim Jordanians can't find work and they blame migrants for taking their jobs.
57
:Jessie
But in reality, forced migrants are doing their best in a really constrained situation, which the policy has created and labor exploitation negatively impacts everyone in both the formal and informal labor market.
58
:Jessie
And as we've already discussed, asylum seekers in the UK can be put in some really constraining situations by policy. Megan, do you have any examples to share?
59
:Megan
Yeah, so quite a few of the participants in my research talked about the impact of dispersal policies. The very disruptive and unpredictable nature of dispersal means people can be separated from the caring communities and relationships that they might have built in one specific place. And it's not just the immediate effects of being dispersed when these policies are actually put into action, but also the precarity and uncertainty that comes with the threat of what might happen.
60
:Megan
People talked about struggling to plan for their future or to make connections with the local community, while the threat of being moved at any time hangs over them. So, for example, one of my research participants who has a disabled spouse avoided claiming asylum support altogether as they were worried that they'd be moved away from their local health specialists.
61
:Megan
And this meant they had no legal source of income for the year it took to process their asylum claim, which was then accepted. So during that entire year, they resorted to selling home cooked meals and hand crocheted baby clothes to local community members to try and cover their bills. Although if the Home Office had been made aware of this, it likely would have compromised their asylum claim.
62
:Megan
Something I think important to note is that, in theory, they could have asked to stay local due to a health exemption, but they didn't trust that the Home Office could care for their best interests and so decided to fend for themselves. People are expected to be sort of self-sufficient and care for themselves, while also denied the capacity to do that.
63
:Olivia
I've seen similar examples in my research to Megan. One participant in my research was in fact moved to a different city by the Home Office, despite the fact that they had a letter from their GP emphasizing how that would be detrimental to their health and ongoing care. So the concerns of the participants in your research and are not unfounded.
64
:Olivia
Some of the other participants in my research have also been moved several times. Whilst they await a decision on their asylum claim or wait for their appeal to be processed. These moves also often happen at short notice. For example, one research participant I worked with lived in five places in just two and a half years, sometimes only receiving a few days notice that they would be moved.
65
:Olivia
They describe to me how once they got into the taxi, not knowing at all where they would even be moved to. Like we've mentioned, this can be very unsettling and leads to a constant fear of being moved, making it difficult to put down roots in one place or to accumulate too many belongings. In another instance, a family was given a few days notice that they would be moved to a different city after living in the same hotel for multiple years.
66
:Olivia
It was school holidays, and so their children didn't even get a chance to tell their friends they were leaving or say goodbye. They were moved to another accommodation. Several hours away before the school term resumed. It's this movement and uncertainty which contributes to hotels being characterized as a precarious form of accommodation in my research.
67
:Jessie
So people staying in hotels or other accommodation facilities are extremely limited in their choices, if not basically totally controlled by the immigration policy. That's both caring and uncaring. Additionally, those are kind of secondary forms of displacement. We also haven't had the time to get into what happens after someone's asylum claim is accepted. But the UK government's policy has been to revoke new refugees housing 28 days after they're awarded refugee status.
68
:Jessie
ss or risk of homelessness in:
69
:Jessie
They no longer care. And that uncaring has really devastating effects.
70
:Jessie
Okay. Well, I want to thank you both. These are really important examples of how people cope with these certain forms of care from above. We've seen how the state's immigration policy is governed through care, either from withholding it or enacting it as a form of control.
71
:Megan
Yeah, exactly. That's what my concept of a callous, bordering speaks to. This idea that care is essential to how we think about bordering on migration governance. It's not just that some populations are excluded from state care, although that often is also the case, but also that where care or support is offered can also be exclusionary. This concept helps us move beyond the idea of care as this wholly benevolent thing, and instead to be more attentive to the ways in which care can be mobilized as a form of coercive control.
72
:Megan
There's also this idea that care, or at least the language of care, can legitimize bordering it sanitizes border controls in ways that make them feel reasonable, even caring, while at the same time people are being detained, despised, denied access, and even dying as a result of these policies. And I also think that's what can make it so difficult to resist, because it comes wrapped in this language of support and of the state meeting its obligation to care for people, but purely on its own terms.
73
:Megan
So when I say careless bordering, I'm trying to hold that tension. And it's not just the absence of care, but recognizing that care structurally implicated in these harms.
74
:Jessie
And Olivia, this links us back to the concept that you've also introduced the idea that the state can care too much for populations considered not deserving.
75
:Olivia
Yes, exactly. So the idea of the state caring too much for people who are perceived as undeserving of care has been really problematic in recent years. The general public are constantly being bombarded with this idea that large numbers of people are crossing the channel as illegal immigrants to live in taxpayer funded luxury hotels. Meaning that people's needs inside the hotels are often ignored.
76
:Olivia
In reality, these people are seeking safety and left to survive in poor quality accommodation rather than being shown care. Asylum seekers are met with difficult living conditions, hostility and control. These issues have also led to tensions in communities, particularly when people feel that care from the state is unevenly distributed and that the state is providing too much care to people who are not citizens, especially during difficult times.
77
:Olivia
In reality, a large portion of the resources and funding being spent on asylum accommodation is going to just a very small number of people who are profiting from the large companies delivering these contracts. Across the board, there's a need for more care for lots of different groups of people and an urgent need for more affordable, quality accommodation for all.
78
:Jessie
Absolutely. These are really helpful formulations which help us see how historic forces of colonialism and power have resounding influences in the day to day lives of refugees and asylum seekers, but also all people in the UK and around the world, as well as how the concept of care can be mobilized in multiple ways to many different ends. Thank you so much to you both, Olivia and Meghan for your input.
79
:Jessie
And thank you to Birkbeck University for hosting the second season of Between Borders. Don't forget to look at our show notes, in which we've also included some questions to guide you through the episode, as well as to reflect further on the ideas we've introduced.
80
:Jessie
In our next episode, we'll turn our attention to care from below, exploring how migrants and communities create alternative networks of care and solidarity within and against these systems. Thank you all for listening and for staying with the trouble of care in these uncaring times.